Walmart charity man shown the door
by Eric Firpo
Oct 30, 2009 | 5238 views | 45 45 comments | 175 175 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Jose Salas was manager of Tracy's Walmart until he was recently terminated. Press file photo
view slideshow (2 images)
For three years now, employees at Walmart in Tracy have helped raise tens of thousands of dollars that were donated to Tracy charities and other groups — over and above the roughly $16,000 the company typically gives away to the community each year.

People stepped forward this week to give much of the credit to store manager Jose Salas — who was abruptly fired recently, to the shock of his supporters in the community and at the store.

What stuns his friends, colleagues and others is the reason Salas thinks he was fired: That he violated store policy by raising extra money via in-store employee bake sales and potlucks and — perhaps the last straw — selling to Walmart workers, at a discount, damaged merchandise that would otherwise be thrown away.

Five months into Walmart’s fiscal year, local employees had already raised about $18,000, according to Dianne Timan, who retired from the store after 15 years and still has contacts and close friends inside the store.

Over the years, money was given to a virtual who’s who of charities and groups in town, such as the McHenry House Family Shelter, the Tracy Women’s Forum, Tracy Interfaith Ministries, local schools, the chamber of commerce and many others.

After Salas was let go, the slightly more than $10,000 left in the charity

kitty was given in one lump sum to Irene Rose of the Tracy Police Department, organizer of Shop with a Cop, an event at Walmart in which developmentally disabled kids are given gift cards and sent on a shopping spree in the store with police officers.

With Salas’ departure, however, friends fear all the extra money once doled out to local groups will evaporate.

“As far as what Jose did for the community, of all the other store managers, Jose was the one that did the most for the community,” said Virginia Taylor, 64, an employee with the Tracy store since it opened in 1993. “If somebody called, whether it be a church or an individual, he was always there trying to do what he could, no matter what the cause was.”

Salas declined to discuss with the Press why he was told he was fired, and phone calls to a Walmart spokesman went unreturned by press time.

But Salas has told Timan and others that he was let go immediately after he admitted to selling damaged merchandise at a discount to employees, despite the fact that much of the resulting money was donated to charity. Some was also saved for an employee Christmas party, Timan said.

Salas told friends that the company gave him no verbal warning and no written reprimand or other sanction before he was fired.

“He should have the same rights and privileges that we have, and that wasn’t given to him,” Taylor said. “As an employee, you have certain lines you go through before you’re terminated. He was never given that.”

Timan and others also say the discounted sale of damaged goods to employees for fundraising was a common practice at other stores. While she worked there, Timan said, district managers and other Walmart higher-ups visited the store and saw what was going on — and sometimes bought goods themselves — but never said anything was wrong with the practice.

“What he was doing was being done in every other store,” Taylor said. “I know this for a fact. And what he was doing was to raise funds for charity.”

Employee morale has sunk to lows Taylor has never seen since the local store opened, and she said raising money has come to a screeching halt since Salas left.

“We’re not doing any of that any more,” Taylor said. “He’s going to be a big, big loss for the community. The next store manager is going to be very hesitant to do anything.”

Salas, a married father of three who grew up in Lodi and now lives in French Camp, says he has made phone calls to managers in the days since he was let go in an effort to get his job back, without success.

On Tuesday, he said he has a phone call scheduled with one high-level executive, but he doesn’t have a whole lot of hope left.

“The company’s always been good to me,” Salas said, “’till now. I just don’t think they’re being fair, or consistent.”
Comments
(45)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
WinnebagoJoe
|
November 06, 2009
I don't think we should choose to scream and yell at others like we are the judge of others. Even if they do wrong. Maybe that guy was the homeless guy in the MotorHome. Out in the parking lot.

But why scream and yell about it?
workerBee
|
November 06, 2009
(((KILLER INSTINCT)))

WELL, I STILL WORK IN WAL-MART BECAUSE I KNOW HOW TO NOT GOSSIP LIKE OTHERS AND I DO NOT FIGHT OVER MEN DURING WORK HOUR'S ETC... I HAVE RESPECT FOR MYSELF AND MY WORK! ALSO IF YOU ARE SO ANGRY AT THE FACT THAT JOSE "SUPPOSEBLY" YELLED AT THE THIEF THEN MAYBE YOU SHOULD HAVE BEEN REAL AND STEP'D UP TO HIM!! I HONESTLY THINK IT MUST OF BEEN YOUR BROTHER OR YOUR HUSBAND!LOL.. HOW DO YOU EXPECT JOSE TO TAKE THAT OK WHEN HE DOES HIS BEST AT WORK AND SEE'S A PERSON STEALING THAT IS UP TO NO GOOD!! MAYBE SOME ONE SHOULD TELL HIM THAT STEALING IS A BAD THING! JOSE DID A GOOD JOB AND NO MATTER WHAT NEGATIVE LAZY AND IGNORANT PEOPLE HAVE TO SAY ABOUT SALAS HE IS A GREAT PERSON AND A GOOD MANAGER! MAYBE HE FIRED LAZY PEOPLE THAT DID NOT WANT TO DO THERE JOB!! WORK HARD GET PAID GOOD!! JOSE KNEW WHAT HE WAS DOING!! IT ALL WENT TO A GOOD "CAUSE"!!! NOT LIKE HE WAS POCKETING AND BEING GREEDY WITH THE MONEY! HESPLIT IT IN MANY WAY'S!!!

IT MUST BE THE LAZY FIRED PEOPLE WRITEING NEGATIVE TOUGHTS ABOUT HIM! DO NOT BE MAD CUASE U WERE LET GO!!! I STAND BEHIND JOSE SALAS!! HE IS A GREAT MAN ALWAY'S WILL BE!!! I WORK AT WAL-MART AND HE IS THE BEST MANAGER IN THERE!! OR WAS!!! I AM AMUSED OFF WHAT THESE SORRY PPL HAVE TO SAY!! BTW I DON'T LIVE OFF UNEMPLOYMENT!!! U DO!!! AND I OWN MY VERY OWN HOUSE AND LOVE MY LIFE!! JOSE WILL BE MISSED!!! THE LORD KNOW'S ABOUT JOSE'S CAUSE AND HE KNOW'S IT WAS ALL FOR A GOOD 1!! HE WILL MAKE JUSTICE FOR HIM!!
Killerinstinct
|
November 06, 2009
Worker bee and others just dont know what else to write. Worker bee is saying that people who talk negative about Jose Salas are lazy and got fired. Worker bee is probably collecting uneployment and living with his mom. everytime I went to Walmart Jose Salas gave me the worst attitude. He always walked around like he didnt care. I dont think the other associates should have been fired because of Jose. Some were subourdinates, but the ones who werent then yes. For the supporters of Jose what's going to happen if one day he admits to theft not saying he committed theft, but now what are you still going to say aww Jose was a great guy. People find a job and stop chatting here about things you dont know. Once someone I know got arrested shoplifting at Walmart and I was there. The security guy had him in the office handcuffed. A few minutes later Jose Salas showed up and chewed him up. He spoke to him like he was garbage.The police came and picked him up. Maybe Jose felt like that guy did.
nevagivup
|
November 05, 2009
Workerbee. Good point when associates are told that they are not allowed to be reading "certain" articles in the store or even have it where anyone would be able to see it.All of a sudden they "DISAPPEARED" Isn't there some Amendment Right we have of Freedom of speech as Americans? Or not if you work for Walmart? Like a Jury, a right to a court and Jury before you are found guily and given a sentence. And as far as the incentives the store once had, they are all gone. Along with the community programs, and involment we once did, it's too bad that from all this only more and more people will continue to loose and be hurt. And it all started with the best intensions. Hang in there Jose.
workerBee
|
November 05, 2009
i work for wal-mart and i can explain all the negative comments about jose salas. they are mostly coming from people that have been fired, lazy, etc. gossip ridden people that lack integrity have nothing good to say because he did his job as a store manager. he was a good person and even rehired some associates after they were layed off. he valued his workers when they deserved that recognition. ive been at wal-mart for a little over two years, i never once saw any misconduct from him. the store has changed since hes been gone. we used to have bbq's and potlucks etc. and now, well now we get one donut per person if that. the lp refused to let us get a hold of the tracy press at work due to what was said in the article. are we borderlining totalitarian nazi standards? we miss you and wish the best for you and the ones closest to you jose salas.
MarleyNMe
|
November 04, 2009
Why fire all the WalMart employees? Maybe they thought it was "charity"? Christmas is coming. Time to damage some goods?
smarterthanyou
|
November 04, 2009
First of all. Jose did not give the press the pictures or the story....so just give it a rest. If he did wrong he is taking the punishment but why should he be the only one. If you want to be fair then fire everyone involved. And jxr if you don't know then shut up.
jxr2009
|
November 03, 2009
I THINK JOSE SALAS NEEDS TO STEP UP AND BE A MAN, IF YOU ASK ME I KINDA FIND A RESEMBLANCE BETWEEN JOSE AND THE PENGUIN FROM BATMAN. ANYWAYS HE NEEDS TO STEP UP, STOP GIVING THE PRESS CUTE PICTURES ABOUT THE GREAT TIMES HE HAD WITH WALMART, AND ADMIT THAT WHAT HE DID WAS WRONG AND HE COULD HAVE BEEN PROSECUTED FOR WHAT HE DID. SOME OF THE PEOPLE WHO SUPPORT HIM WHERE PROBABLY GETTING DISCOUNTED MERCHANDISE THAT WALMART WAS GOING TO OTHERWISE THROW AWAY. DID JOSE SALAS POCKETED MONEY WE DON'T KNOW. HOW MUCH MONEY DID JOSE SALAS POCKETED WHO KNOWS. WAS HE COMMITING OTHER ANTI-INTEGRITY ACTIONS WHO KNOWS.
package
|
November 03, 2009
Perhaps Wal-mart does not want to be sued by some lawsuit happy customers over the defective or damaged items? Who knows, one could give one person unknown to Walmart as a "gift" and they could attempt to either get a refund or sue them?

If that is so, it might help to prevent further loss to the business establishment.

Just wild guess.

CN
freedomofspeach
|
November 03, 2009
Billions of dollars are lost and stolen annually from businesses, because of employee theft. Employee dishonesty and theft costs U.S. business over $50 billion dollars annually. National estimates show that 75% of all employees steal from their employers at least once throughout their careers. The same statistics show that at least half of these 75% steal multiple times from their employer.



Ms. Salas states that Wal-Mart gave him no verbal warning and no written reprimand or other sanction before the corporate fired him. However, during Mr. Salas interview with Eric Firpo, Mr. Salas refused to comment on the real reason the company let him go. Furthermore, Dianne Timan relates Mr. Salas message publicly stating, “Mr. Salas was let go immediately after he admitted to selling damaged merchandise at a discount to employees, despite the fact that much of the resulting money was donated to charity, in addition to some of the unauthorized sales revenue was also allocated for an employee Christmas party”.

Virginia Taylor, a Wal-Mart employee states, “He should have the same rights and privileges that we have, and that wasn’t given to him,” Taylor said. “As an employee, you have certain lines you go through before you’re terminated. He was never given that.”

Dianne Timan states, “Others also say the discounted sale of damaged goods to employees for fundraising was a common practice at other stores”. While she worked there, Timan said, “district managers and other Wal-Mart higher-ups visited the store and saw what was going on — and sometimes bought goods themselves — but never said anything was wrong with the practice. What he was doing was being done in every other store,” Taylor said. “I know this for a fact. And what he was doing was to raise funds for charity.”

Criminal law defines theft as the act of an unauthorized taking of someone else’s property belonging to another person with the intent to deprive the owner or the person with its rightful possession of the property, use, or monetary value. Wal-Mart is a powerful chain of stores, and they have an army of legal counsels knowledgeable in labor as well as corporate laws. I see no violations in the labor laws and due process on Mr. Salas case. An administrator interrogates Mr. Salas regarding the allegations of unauthorized and unethical sale of merchandise to store employees; Mr. Salas not only admits the charges, but also states the lengthy history of his actions, the article accounts for $44,000.00 and that is all a legal counsel needs to attain a successful litigation.

Mr. Salas should have had a notion of things closing in on him, and that would have been the time for him to hire a legal counsel to help him plea bargain, (if is true that Ms. Taylor has credible evidence of every other Wal-Mart Store Manager is defrauding the corporation).

anastar2
|
November 03, 2009
nevagyvup, obviously loss prevention did say something or else he wouldnt have been questioned, tthey have to observe the situation and this is a process. he admitted to it and this story is only from jose's point of view.

yes giving to charity is great but not when something doesnt belong to you. what wouldve been even greater was letting his employees who did well for the store and SAVED the store thousands of dollars keep their jobs so they wouldnt need to be unemployed which in the end results in a former employee joining the womens foundation or mchenry house, etc. Instead he backs up his buddy's who cry that they have an issue with someone and then has them fired.

hey its a sad thing to lose a job but hes not the only one with a family to support.
FrostySnowball
|
November 03, 2009
Ahem,

It's not a crime to give to charity (or not give). The issue becomes one of who get's what. When the product is destroyed then WalMart is not liable. And fewer boxes get marked as damaged goods. If you count the number of employee trucks and trunks in the back door you will know where the damaged goods gogogo. This happened at a sporting goods company. People thought there was "nothing wrong with it". Finally, they brought out the total bill (after a spot inventory) and it was over $30,000 dollars. The company went bankrupt because of it and those employees who were STEALING did more DAMAGE than GOOD. If you want a sale go to the flea market and keep your conscience clean. SaveMart give damaged food away? Baked goods for free? No? Why not? Free moldy bread for the homeless, anyone? Nope. It doesn't happen that way.
tracylover
|
November 03, 2009
I don't know the facts for his firing, but I can tell you for a fact that the clearance items that do not sell are supposed to be put in a trash compactor and destroyed even if they are viable product. Walmart does NOT give it to charity even though it could be used, they destroy. Fashion Bug does the same thing. I think the bigger crime here is why is a corporation destroying good product when there are so many people in need.
MarleyNMe
|
November 02, 2009
Well, some people here may not have gotten their discounts when they crushed a package?

And others got their discounts when they wrote "damaged" on a WalMart box with a black magic marker?

Who knows, but this job was not to write off the entire inventory, whenever some 22 year old Electronics Manager wanted a free MP3 player.

If you go to work for WalMart you have to remember you also have to represent your employer in fairness.

Your loyalties lie to the company that employees you. Not you buddy for the week who buys you a MickieD's burger for lunch.

I don't know, but if I worked for WalMart, I would have kept a spread sheet and presented it to upper management and told them "THERE IS AN AWFUL LOT OF SH!T GOING OUT THE DOOR".

They would have said. "NO SH!T". And what are you doing about it?

nevagivup
|
November 02, 2009
Too bad all you ignorant idiots who are too stupid to have the ability to read the story because all the facts were written in it.Just because you once worked at Walmart and you your self was the reason for being terminated, don't now try to put the blame on him.That's why after you got fired you were the same one coming in and calling Jose to ask for your jobs back.Save that crap for your My Space or Facebook, and let real readers who care comment. Beyond the point.As written any money (which by the way was over $10,000)that was raised for the charities was given all to Shop with a Cop which is a local Tracy charity.So what money did he take?And yes your right.Loss Prevention does have access to see and look at whats going on.Yet they seen it along with others who visited the store and not once did anyone say any Policy was being broken.And yes merchandise was being given away.Diapers, formula,soap,school supplies,cleaners, that other wise would have been thrown away, or disposed of.So I guess instead of giving to local schools and Womans Shelters ect. it would have been better to throw items away. GO GREEN?! Guess not.Save costs at store level? Guess not if its going to risk jobs.
anonymous
|
November 02, 2009
"But Salas has told Timan and others that he was let go immediately after he admitted to selling damaged merchandise at a discount to employees"

If there is a written policy banning this behavior, the result could easily lead to immediate termination. Even if others were doing it.

Kind of an odd story though without having the facts of the termination and or a statement from the company.

anonymous
|
November 02, 2009
Does Walmart give out protocols/requirements for employees and upper management to carry out upon their being hired?
jxr2009
|
November 02, 2009
ALL JOSE IS DOING IS ADVERTISING TO OTHER EMPLOYERS THAT HE'S DISHONEST AND A THIEF. PUTTING A DIFFERENT FACE SO PEOPLE CAN SEE HIM AS A GOOD PERSON. HE'S FAKE AND HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN PROSECUTED JUST LIKE ANY OTHER DISHONEST EMPLOYEE. NOW THINK ABOUT IT HE CALLED THE TRACY PRESS AND GAVE THEM PICTURES OF HIM LOOKING KINDA FEMINISH IF YOU ASK ME, BUT HEY THAT'S JUST MY OPINION. AND HE WANTS THE COMMUNITY TO SEE THEM. THAT'S NOT GOING TO GET HIM HIS JOB BACK. AND I HOPE ALL THE COMPANIES FIND OUT WHAT HE DID. STEALING FROM YOUR OWN JOB, AND GUYS PLEASE THERE'S MORE TO THIS STORY. DO YOU RELLY THINK LOSS PREVENTION FIRED HIM JUST FOR SELLING MERCHANDISE TO EMPLOYEES HMMM LOL RIGHT!!!!

LOSS PREVENTION PROBABLY GOT HIM FOR ALOT OF MONEY, I JUST DON'T KNOW WHY THEY SPARED HIM FROM GOING TO JAIL. WELL WHO KNOWS MAYBE HE CAN USE THE HIS DISHONESTY SKILLS AS A LIVING. AND PEOPLE STOP BACKING HIM UP IF YOU DON'T WORK LOSS PREVENTION THEN KEEP IT TO YOURSELF. YOU DON'T SEE WHAT THEY SEE.
anastar2
|
November 02, 2009
needless to say all of the employees who are backing him up were probably getting free items at the expense of walmart. all of the people who were getting free merchandise we would all like to hear what you have to say .... * you should probably be terminated because that is stealing from walmart* im sure walmart does not buy merchandise to give away.
anastar2
|
November 02, 2009
i agree magic1960 , walls may not be able to talk but cameras sure do and i know for a fact that the people defending Jose and thinking he was a really great guy are the ass kissers of the store. As for 'GoSteelers' loss prevention has access that most store employees don't and can see everything that goes on behind the scenes. what he was doing was wrong and he is trying to put on the "poor soul" act wen he had many good employees fired simply because he did not want to deal with them or did not like them or was afraid he would get caught in the act. ... by the way im sure Walmart didn't tip off the media so i wonder who did... hint hint this article is not going to get his job back!


We encourage readers to share online comments in this forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a space for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Comments that stray from the topic of the story or are found to contain abusive language are subject to removal at the Press’ discretion, and the writer responsible will be subject to being blocked from making further comments and have their past comments deleted. Readers may report inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.