State scrambles to keep Carnegie open
by Bob Brownne
Sep 25, 2009 | 3867 views | 2 2 comments | 15 15 recommendations | email to a friend | print
The California Sportfishing Protection Alliance has filed a lawsuit aimed at forcing Carnegie State Vehicular Recreation Area to prevent soil from the hillside of Corral Hollow Canyon from ending up in Corral Hollow Creek.  File photo.
The California Sportfishing Protection Alliance has filed a lawsuit aimed at forcing Carnegie State Vehicular Recreation Area to prevent soil from the hillside of Corral Hollow Canyon from ending up in Corral Hollow Creek. File photo.
State parks officials are scrambling to find a way to keep Carnegie State Vehicular Recreation Area open after an Alameda County judge on Tuesday gave the parks department a choice between cleaning up Corral Hollow Creek or forbidding off-road vehicles in the park.

Judge Frank Roesch issued the order in response to a lawsuit filed last week by the California Sportfishing Protection Alliance, an environmental watchdog group that pressures regulatory agencies to follow the letter of the law when it comes to monitoring potential degradation of waterways.

In this case, the CSPA set its sights on Corral Hollow Creek, a seasonal creek that runs through Carnegie and out to the valley floor. The creek channel, which is dry for most of the year, ends in farmland south of Tracy. Except in the heaviest rainy seasons, water from Corral Hollow Canyon is absorbed into the ground before it reaches the San Joaquin River.

In addition to regular weekend use, Carnegie is host to two American Motorcyclist Association hill climb events this fall, including the third round of the 2009 California AMA series on Oct. 3 and 4. Those events are still on while lawyers from the parks department, the CSPA and the Regional Water Quality Control Board decide what to do next.

The CSPA says the increased sediment caused by motorcycle use at the park has the potential to degrade water quality in the canyon’s watershed. According to the lawsuit, the California Department of Parks and Recreation is obligated to take out a permit to allow addition of soil and sediment to the creek, or take out a waiver in lieu of a permit.

In any event, the state would have to determine how much soil is added to the creek and test water samples to determine if off-road vehicle use causes water pollution, then file a report on that study.

Roesch’s order requires that, by Wednesday, the parks department provide that report to the Regional Water Quality Control Board. In the meantime, it must halt all off-road vehicle use at the park.

Bob Williamson, district superintendent for Carnegie SVRA, said the matter must go through Department of Parks and Recreation lawyers before any changes are made at the park. In the meantime, next weekend’s hill climb will go on as planned.

“From what I understand, operations will continue,” Williamson said. “I don’t expect that there will be any effect on the hill climb.”

Skip Horne, organizer of the Carnegie hill climbs, said he will meet with parks officials to find out what needs to be done to keep the events on the calendar. Meanwhile, folks in the off-road vehicle community are trying to understand how water quality could be harmed in a creek that is dry most of the year.

“This whole thing is absolutely

ludicrous,” Horne said. “It’s another ploy by the environmental world to get rid of us.”

Horne added that he has always been under pressure to take care of hillsides and make sure hill climb trails don’t get overused.

“(The issue) was there when we got here, and it will be here for eternity,” he said, adding that he has seen the state take water samples in the spring, but they can’t take samples for most of the year.

“My thinking is this judge hasn’t a clue that there isn’t any water in there for most of the year.”

Bill Jennings, executive director of the CSPA, said his group has monitored water quality during the rainy season when the creek flows.

“During the fall storms, we monitored water coming into the park and water leaving the park. What we found were prodigious amounts of heavy metals and sediment,” he said, adding that the parks department should have similar results from its own tests.

“Every time it rains, there is a sediment load washing down. They knew about that and ignored it.”

Jennings added that the CSPA’s goal is not to shut down the park, but to make sure that sediment from the canyon’s slopes is kept out of the creek bed and that the creek bed is protected from off-road vehicles.

“We want them to comply with the law, and they’ve known for a long time that they haven’t followed their own regulations in protecting habitat up there.”

• Contact Bob Brownne at 830-4227 or
Comments-icon Post a Comment
December 15, 2009
Let's see here, a hillbilly might look like someone on a farm, wearing britches, a loose shirt and no shoes. He might also be sucking on a piece of hay,sitting on a disc harrow pulled by a horse to plow some fields.

That would also describe Philo Farnsworth the inventor of electronic Television when he got the inspiration for the most important invention of the last century.

I'll take a cowboy or a hillbilly and day over a fool who disburses semantic garbage from a brain cavity that can't produce a full sentence in the English language.

September 25, 2009
Skip Horne..what a frickin ignorant hill billy!! LMAO!!!

We encourage readers to share online comments in this forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a space for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Comments that stray from the topic of the story or are found to contain abusive language are subject to removal at the Press’ discretion, and the writer responsible will be subject to being blocked from making further comments and have their past comments deleted. Readers may report inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at